READ MSG from PLC5E to ML1200 through ENI = FAIL

TheWaterboy

Lifetime Supporting Member + Moderator
Join Date
May 2006
Location
-27.9679796,153.419016
Posts
1,923
I have followed KB 19726
My controller is a PLC5E rev J.
The 1761-ENI is FW revision 3.22 .
Connection is Ethernet
SCADA system can read registers in the ML1200 just fine
Logix500 can program the PLC just fine.

Yet I have a PLC5 that will not read from the ML1200 using the following

PLC-5 Typed Read to SLC
Multihop is port 2 to IP address x.x.x.48
ContrologixBackplane to Address 0 (this was part of KB 19726)

The Error is either
Error #18 Connection is broken (if backplane IS NOT specified in multihop)
or
Error #15 Connection not completed because connection was broken
(if backplane IS specified in multihop).

What am I missing here?
 
My first instinct is to suspect that the Net-ENI is out of TCP connections. It's notorious for only having six; two incoming, two outgoing, and two in either direction.

If your SCADA and RSLogix are both making connections, maybe there's an RSLinx station or something else taking up both of the others, leaving the MSG instruction without a resource.

A Wireshark trace would tell us for sure if it's a TCP problem or some other layer of the system.

There's a Knowledgebase article about using Telnet to read the TCP connection status of a Net-ENI, if you want to check it out that way.
 
Yes this thread is old but I did solve this problem and wanted to add the solution.

The ENI MAY SAY it will do 6 connections but it will not reliably. I have 2 of them in 2 different machines and a spare and they all do that same thing. 4 connections max and all is fine. I was able to repeat this over and over again that 6 connections will make it become unreliable.

Wound up using a CLX plc to concentrate the data from the ENI connected ML1200 and having that as its only connection fixed all its problems.
 

Similar Topics

Does anyone know if is possible to read data out of a ProfaceHMI/PLC into a CompactLogix PLC? I have a bunch of OEM machines on our plant floor...
Replies
2
Views
484
Hello Everyone, Can two PLCs on two different subnets pass data via CIP MSG Read Instructions? I would be using the HMS Fl3xy NAT 1:1 feature to...
Replies
6
Views
2,457
So I have a micrologix 1500 on network through an ENI. I need to read an integer from it to my SLC5/05 so I can stop pumps when the remote tank is...
Replies
7
Views
2,021
Yesterday I was working with an Allen-Bradley Controllogix and a Compactlogix. I was using a MSG instruction to read from the Controllogix via...
Replies
0
Views
1,124
The Ethernet has 3 pieces of PLC5 processors (PLC5-40E), for easy explanations, we name A,B and C. All pings are OK and RSLogix5 can connect all...
Replies
13
Views
4,882
Back
Top Bottom