running an AC coil on DC

lesmar96

Lifetime Supporting Member
Join Date
May 2017
Location
PA
Posts
520
Would like your input........

I am not sure I know all how a shunt trip breaker works, but the ones I am used to you use a control voltage signal to trip the breaker.

I have a customer ( and I don't have all the details) that has a tripping coil rated for 125VAC. Now he needs it to run on 125VDC for whatever reason. Is it possible to run a coil like that on either AC or DC? What will happen?
 
Coil impedance increases with frequency, higher the frequency lower the current and with DC the impedance is minimal.

If you run with 125 VDC probably it will burn in a matter of seconds , don't try it.

The coil should be changed for other rated for 125 VDC
 
Last edited:
My customer came up with the idea to run a bridge rectifier in reverse to run this coil. I don't think there is any way this will work. A recitifer cuts the sine wave, right? to take the hz out of it? Running it in reverse, there is no way that it will be able to build a sine wave? He is sure that he has done this before, and it worked, but I don't see how.

Any thoughts?
 
Coil impedance increases with frequency, higher the frequency lower the current and with DC the impedance is minimal.

If you run with 125 VDC probably it will burn in a matter of seconds , don't try it.

The coil should be changed for other rated for 125 VDC

Agree with the above response.
I saw a customer hook up several 24VAC rated relay coils to 24VDC and they all got hot very quickly.
 
My customer came up with the idea to run a bridge rectifier in reverse to run this coil. I don't think there is any way this will work. A recitifer cuts the sine wave, right? to take the hz out of it? Running it in reverse, there is no way that it will be able to build a sine wave? He is sure that he has done this before, and it worked, but I don't see how.

Any thoughts?

Is he joking?

Yeah it's diodes cutting the sine wave, in reverse the dc would see either a "brick wall" or a short circuit.

An inverter would do the trick, but that sounds more expensive/complicated than just getting the correct relay?
 
Last edited:
The are 2 types of trip units.... "Shunt Trip" and "Undervoltage Trip".
A "Shunt Trip" device trips on voltage applied.
An "Undervoltage Trip" device trips on loss of voltage.

These can be ordered at different voltage levels.
 
I don't mean to suggest this as any kind of practical solution but I believe you will find that an AC rated coil in a relay will operate successfully at a much lower DC voltage. You can play around with one in the lab and I believe that if you start very low with the DC and come up slowly, you will reach a voltage where the coil will attract the armature and not overheat.

This is not to recommend doing this. It might do if your life was at risk and you were stranded on a remote island with nothing but variable DC power but few other places.

If you disassemble an AC relay coil, you will find that it is simply a coil of wire (just like the DC version) but with a bronze shading ring around the nose of the magnetic core.

Without the shading ring, you would have a 60hz buzzer much like a motor starter with an AC coil and a broken shading ring. You have to replace the coil to get the starter to stop chattering but really, all you need to replace is the broken shading ring (comes with the new coil).

Of course, the AC coil is wound with different inductance and wire turns if the voltage was to be the same AC for DC in addition to the shading ring.
 
Not reliable - been there - done that! Works sometimes and not other times.
 

Similar Topics

Good Morning , We have a IMI Buschjost 24 vdc solenoid valve coil that is very hot . About 192 degrees . It stays energized for very long...
Replies
5
Views
2,363
A new point I/O rack is to be hooked up with the running PLC. In point I/O, it is supposed to be the OA4 card to be installed as per the...
Replies
1
Views
72
Hi, I received this SIMATIC S7-300 training kit for maintenance. When I power it up, the PLC doesn't go to RUN mode and the STOP mode led is...
Replies
7
Views
250
Hi I got a powerFlex 525 AC Drive (used) i changed parameter t053 to 2 to do factory reset and now i have both parameters 46 and 47 on 1 but cant...
Replies
2
Views
130
Word of warning. I had issues with a 5069-AENTR not appearing in IO selection. After downloading the latest version 40 AOP, still didn't appear...
Replies
0
Views
123
Back
Top Bottom