Issue with clamp meters

rejoe.koshy

Member
Join Date
Dec 2011
Location
kolkata
Posts
193
Hey guys,
I am facing an issue with clamp meters, to resolve which I need a little bit of assistance.
I had installed a 30 KW motor which belongs to air compressor and post its installation when I checked its current on all three phases (on load) I was surprised since it showed huge imbalance (72, 84, 75) and was seen to be on the higher side.I checked mechanical side but everything seemed to be fine.

Moreover , the motor wasnt getting hot and nor was the overload relay getting actuated. This got me thinking as to whether the motor is actually drawing such high imbalance currents.

I replaced my meter with another one but showed the same results...Now I am confused as to what to conclude.

Could this be a meter issue or a wrong measurement technique?

Pls help
 
Last edited:
Motor voltage & connection

Check the motor connection maybe its in delta connection and it should be in star
read the motor name plate and make sure the right voltage and frequency is connected
Good luck
 
The motor is run via star-delta starter. The frequency and voltage is as per its rated value and the current is measured post its switch over to delta connection.
 
Clamp meters are basically inaccurate and the measurement can be altered by other inductive fields apart from the cable you measure.
Measure de current in another cable passage, maybe you will read different values.
 
Can the current measurement on one phase be affected by the magnetic field of the current on the other phase?

If so, what are the chances...because since the motor does not get too hot and nor does its overload relay trip I am not really convinced that the motor is actually drawing such high currents.
 
How does the current imbalance compare with the voltage imbalance? If you find the voltage to be more consistent, then the current imbalance is probably due to physical differences in the motor. You are showing a current imbalance of over 10%. I generally worry about anything greater than 5%.
 
Hi

Check the incoming/outgoing voltage, motor winding resistance also star/delta/main contractor pole resistances. One of these may point to the issue.
 
How does the current imbalance compare with the voltage imbalance? If you find the voltage to be more consistent, then the current imbalance is probably due to physical differences in the motor. You are showing a current imbalance of over 10%. I generally worry about anything greater than 5%.

The voltage was observed to be consistent(1 % variation).In any case should nt the overload relay trip , which is set at 34 A (installed on the phases)?
 
I wouldn't concern over 1% voltage variance (that's good) and definitely wouldn't cause current imbalance of 10%.
Easiest thing to try is winding resistance test when motor is at a stand still, if they're not balanced then thats your problem.

Regarding meter not reading right or being influenced, I've never seen a reading vary (notably anyway) when in a noisy environment or even with the outside of the clamp resting against another phase, even if this does happen it wouldn't cause a 12A/10% difference IMO. If it was your meter then it would consistently read the same amount out roughly on all phases or repeating the test would give different results.
 

Similar Topics

Rockwell Tech Support seemed to have hit a wall with this question. Already updated the version to 5.00.13 per their suggestio but am still...
Replies
1
Views
58
We have a problem where client wrongly install inverters in their residence, this then prevents the elec meters(Hexing hxp100Dii) from...
Replies
0
Views
69
Hello all. I need some help on DLR issue we encountered which is the DLR not working when supervisor is disconnected from the ring. FIrst of all...
Replies
4
Views
102
I'm using legacy recipe to download a recipe to the PLC. A little background, the recipes are large. They are broken down into 6 tables, each 16...
Replies
2
Views
78
I have a project that is loading pallets into 10 test bays and then unloading them when the test is complete. I am using an array to store which...
Replies
3
Views
163
Back
Top Bottom