Radio modems!

mitakka

Member
Join Date
Mar 2017
Location
SZ
Posts
14
Hi all! Could you please suggest me the best producers of radio modems with wide range antennas and rs485 interface?
The purpose is covering 8km area with multiple compressors stations and reading their parameters via radio.
The data will be stored in a PLC.
Thanks in advance!
:)
 
I've used the FreeWave FGR2 series mentioned with success. Schneider has radios but I haven't tried them yet.
 
What sort of topography? line of sight? What sort of laws apply in your country? How much data? How fast do you need to poll?

I have become a fan of the Phoenix TWE for unlicensed FHSS 900 Mhz. We use them with add on I/O modules where the processing logic can be remote (simple water well controls and tank monitoring).

We have a customer using the Freewave and they link up and work well, but have not been very rugged. They had two failures back to back simply because of a surge arrestor that my multimeter could detect no problem with.

I think the Digi XTend (replaced by Xtream) series is more reliable for a cheap 900MHz radio.

For licensed UHF radios, I have only worked with a couple of different brands. For a simple serial radio, we have good luck with Maxon 174E. It is cheap and simple to configure. I have also worked with Cal Amp Viper SC400 series and they are probably great if you are an IT guru. They seem to work well and fast when they are working...But then they mysteriously stop ... at random intervals ... but for minutes at a time, then start working again. To my purposes, there is too much "IT" cr*p that seems to go on behind the scenes. When you have trouble with a Viper, be prepared to run wireshark on a managed switch when you call tech support. I spent a couple days last week replacing 8 of them with the Maxon after giving up on getting rid of errors with the expensive Vipers. They may appear on ebay in the not too distant future at a discount price so we can recover some of the money wasted on my time trying to clear up intermittent (but persistent) errors.

The Maxons are dirt simple and cheap and have their own issues...but once you get them working, they work until they die from lightning, then you set up a new one in under 3 minutes, slap it in there for under $400 and away you go again until the next thunderstorm....which will destroy any of them even with good surge arrestors.

We have a Maxon (licensed UHF) with a cheap Yagi antenna pointed at a 4 story hotel, with a 200' cliff right behind it, talking to a water plant 4 miles away over another 200' forested hill. I don't know why it works, but it does with over 90% successful read rate (and polling every 4 seconds, this is fine for this situation). Their stupid HD15 connector for power AND serial sucks and the tiny little mounting holes are a PITA, but I have yet to find a radio that has everything done right...The Phoenix TWE is as close as we have come to falling in love with a radio, but can't shoot through buildings and over hills at ~960MHz and low power (I think it is 500mW).

Being in Bulgaria is probably going to be the single most important factor in your choices. All the airwaves are subject to Gubberment oversight...
 
Last edited:
radio modems

I've deployed and configured several of the schneider radios (telepace software) and they are quite impressive. The software interface is quite antiquated (users familiar with win 3.x will recognize the look and feel) but functional. Expect to do a fair bit of reading if you aren't already familiar with radio setups, stuff about masters and networks etc.
 
Expect to do a fair bit of reading if you aren't already familiar with radio setups, stuff about masters and networks etc.

+1 to this, I had to do a fair amount of manual reading and also had a nice chat with the tech support guy from FreeWave.
 
I've deployed and configured several of the schneider radios (telepace software) and they are quite impressive. The software interface is quite antiquated (users familiar with win 3.x will recognize the look and feel) but functional. Expect to do a fair bit of reading if you aren't already familiar with radio setups, stuff about masters and networks etc.

The Schneider Trio Q Ethernet radios are excellent for licenced UHF and now VHF too. Their J series are also good 900Mhz free band radios. Both now have a decent Web interface for set up and the documentation is good. I don't go elsewhere now unless forced to by a client's hardware.
 

Similar Topics

Hello! Is there anyone here who managed to connect two S7 PLCs via radio modems? Please do not answer only in theory. If so, please tell me which...
Replies
5
Views
3,053
Have any of you guys or gals done this?? or have used this brand? If so can you give me some feedback...
Replies
1
Views
2,536
Anyone have any experience, observations, insight etc. when configuring radio modems to function with an Allen-Bradley DF1 Polling Master with...
Replies
4
Views
3,973
I'm trying to communicate the Microwin Software to a S7-200 CPU 226 using two Radio Modems, one of them (Master Radio) connected to the RS-232...
Replies
0
Views
4,054
I have 16 PLC´s S7-200 CPU 224, each one connected to a HMI TD-200. I need to connect all of them to a SCADA using radio modem transmition. The...
Replies
1
Views
5,724
Back
Top Bottom