Isolated vs Non-Isolated RTD Input Card

rajy2r

Member
Join Date
Nov 2006
Location
Canada
Posts
167
I had a question with regards to an Non-Isolated vs Isolated RTD Input Card. This would be for a Flex 1794-IR8 vs Spectrum (1794sc-IF8U or 1794sc-IRT8I).

I understand the Isolated vs Non-Isolated for an analog input due to different power sources, but what is the benefit of a Isolated RTD Input card ? Only thing I can think of is that if one of the RTD's grounds out, would it cause the whole card to fault (i.e. Ground) ?

Would appreciate some feedback.
 
The Spectrum modules are universal input modules, not modules dedicated to RTD inputs only. Universal modules are almost always isolated and do not share a common return or (-) terminal.

The need for isolation becomes apparent with thermocouples or mV signals that can be grounded on the field end, which creates common mode problems with non-isolated analog inputs.

An RTD measurement is based on pumping a fixed, known current source through a field resistor and reading the voltage drop and compensating for wire resistance.

The (reasonable) assumption is that an RTD is isolated from the process so that other electrical (ground) currents do not interfere with the AI card's constant current source. The assumption holds true for all commercial RTD's which are packaged in SS sheaths with MgO insulation electrically isolating the RTD element from the sheath. Since the RTD element itself is isolated from the process, the RTD input board does not have to have the level of isolation that a universal input card does.

I could not find the word 'Isolate' in the AB 1794-IR8 manual so it isn't clear how much isolation is provided with that card.

The Spectrum 1794sc-IRT81 module is a universal temperature input module, it can handle either thermocouple or RTD inputs. Thermocouple inputs desperately need isolation. The RTD's channels get isolation because it's there for the thermocouples, even though it isn't critical for RTDs.

The Spectrum 1794sc-IF8U module has isolation because it is a universal input card handling not only thermocouple or RTD, but 0/4-20mA, current or mV sources.
 

Similar Topics

I am stumped. I haven't run into this before. We have a four wire 4-20mA sensor +PWR -PWR +SIG -SIG We have tested it with a process meter and...
Replies
17
Views
7,775
According to Inputs and Outputs what is the difference in the isolated inputs/outputs as opposed to non-isolated inputs/outputs? And what type of...
Replies
1
Views
1,303
I'm working with a Siemens S7-1215 PLC for the first time. I typically use isolated analog I/O in my projects, but this particular CPU comes with...
Replies
5
Views
5,075
Hi all, please comment on the impacts of changing from isolated analog inputs to non isolated analog inputs. This is for an existing Rockwell 1794...
Replies
3
Views
2,515
Hi all, I am working with a GE 90-30 PLC and a IC693MDL930 isolated relay N.O. output module and have a question. It is my first time working...
Replies
3
Views
2,898
Back
Top Bottom