RSLINX not communicating on RS232

PhilipW,

Thanks very much for taking the time to help this guy. Although I haven't suffered this particular problem, I've had my share of connection problems. This thread provided some great insight.

Grover
 
Does anyone think that PLCs could go to a USB style connection, where you plug it in & it auto configres?

Just thought that would be a nifty feature.
 
The short answer is yes.

The longer answer is maybe. Some issues:

1. PLC products are designed with 20 year lifecycles in mind, whereas PC technologies run through fads every few years. The now ubiquitous USB port has only been around for a few years, and who knows what will replace it in another 2-3years?

2. Plug and Play is nice, but the firmware in the PLC to support it now has to track the Windows OS standards, with all the potential version and compatitbility issues this creates. Bear in mind that PLC's get shut away in electrical cabinets for YEARS without anyone looking at them. What happens if in say 8 years time someone wants to attach to a PLC USB port, and it doesn't work because that antique old USB 2.0 embedded in it only works under " a totally obsolete and unsupported Windows XP that nobody has any more"? Like how many of us have a dedicated DOS machine just to cope with the odd PLC that can only be accessed with a DOS driver?

3. And such a port can only be used for programming, because in order to make USB PnP work, there is a lot of OS software and CPU power required to make it work. I cannot imagine that the PLC guys are quite ready to embed all that functionality into say a PanelView just yet. It's not impossible, after all the PanelViewPlus is running of WindowsCE, so we are not too far removed from achieving this.

It's not a silly idea. These days we have become so accustomed to plugging stuff into the back of our PC and it all just works, that we forget the rather large amount of software and firmware under the bonnet that is making it all go. The question is then... could a rapidly evolving and mutating USB PnP technology be transfered into the automation environment, without loosing the long-term robustness we require?
 
Last edited:
Good post Phillip.
I had never thought how much computing power it takes to do PnP, nor the associated software/firmware requirements.

Still, it'd be pertty durned cool to pop it in the back o me laptop.
 

Similar Topics

Hi, I am trying to read data values from CAT generator via monico(redlion) module to be displayed on factory talk view studio via RSlinx...
Replies
8
Views
4,755
I have network connections through to most processors in our facility. I am wanting to setup a control logix rack for testing and I am trying to...
Replies
7
Views
1,852
Hello, I am new to this group and to the plc. I am trying to connect the plc-5 to my computer using usb serial adapter. I am going to configure...
Replies
17
Views
3,985
This is my first time using Factory Talk ME and I am trying to setup my communications. RSLinx enterprise will not recognize my processor in slot...
Replies
6
Views
3,573
Hi, I am working on a project, where I face a issue with respected to Network Dropout. The PLC is connected to a 16 port unmanaged switch, where...
Replies
7
Views
198
Back
Top Bottom