VMware or Virtual Machine?

NetNathan

Lifetime Supporting Member
Join Date
Nov 2011
Location
Corona, CA
Posts
2,200
Pros and Cons on choice of VMware or Windows Virtual Machine?
Do not need pricing comparison, I know VMware Workstation is about $250 and Windows Virtual Machine is free.
 
Windows Virtual PC: "Where the **** did everything go ? Is this the root directory ? Which directories are bound to the host ? How the hell does the networking function ? Did somebody change the password ? Is this application running inside the VM or outside the VM... is the little pink border the difference ?"

VMWare Workstation: "Let's get to work."
 
So what you are saying Ken is you get what you pay for ��. Kind of like RSLogix and CCW?
 
I used the Windows "XP Mode" VM on one laptop we provided to a customer, who promptly changed and forgot the wrong password and can't seem to figure out how to launch their applications and also get those applications to talk to the connected network.

I realize this could simply be one bad experience coloring my opinion, but it was a strongly negative experience.

Conversely, I purchased VMWare Workstation with my own money and have used it extensively for years. I can send a removable HDD to a customer, have them run VMWare Player, and be reasonably confident they will be able to use the software successfully. I recently did this with a non-English-speaking customer and they had no trouble following my screenshot instructions.

In my opinion the tight integration between host and guest OS in the Windows built-in VM is a drawback because it's hard to figure out the line between them. VMWare is a more clear "here's the VM, running in its window" distinction.

Your mileage may vary, of course. Lots of people prefer VirtualBox as well. But I'm a VMWare adherent and will continue to be.
 
I used the Windows "XP Mode" VM on one laptop we provided to a customer, who promptly changed and forgot the wrong password and can't seem to figure out how to launch their applications and also get those applications to talk to the connected network.

I realize this could simply be one bad experience coloring my opinion, but it was a strongly negative experience.

Conversely, I purchased VMWare Workstation with my own money and have used it extensively for years. I can send a removable HDD to a customer, have them run VMWare Player, and be reasonably confident they will be able to use the software successfully. I recently did this with a non-English-speaking customer and they had no trouble following my screenshot instructions.

In my opinion the tight integration between host and guest OS in the Windows built-in VM is a drawback because it's hard to figure out the line between them. VMWare is a more clear "here's the VM, running in its window" distinction.

Your mileage may vary, of course. Lots of people prefer VirtualBox as well. But I'm a VMWare adherent and will continue to be.

+1 on VMWare if it's a VM you really need to depend on.

Virtualbox is fine for less important things. For me it's been more crash prone.
 
I use VMWare. The microsh!t solutions didn't work. I run Rockwell, Siemens, Mitsubishi and Matched software on my VMWare. I have paid them a lot.
I have been using VMware for over 10 years now. However, I find the company VMWare is totally brain dead when buying or upgrading a license. I find dealing with them painful.
 
I use VM Player which is free. Have not had any problems with yet.

This is no longer true, they have a stipulation for "non-commercial use only". Last I checked it was ~ $100 for the VM Player license.

I rock Workstation.
 
Another vote for VMWare. I use the mac version (VMWare Fusion) and have used VMWare workstation in the past. Both pretty well flawless - in version 6 of Fusion I had VMWare crash maybe once a month, requiring a reboot, but since upgrading to version 7 six months ago it hasn't missed a beat. The only thing that crashes is Windows ;)
 
I have used VMware, Xen for a server, and VirtualBox daily since 2008.

I find virtual box every bit as powerful as VMware, and have had zero problems with it. I can't think of a single reason to recommend VMware over virtualbox
 

Similar Topics

Hi all, I want to move a virtual machine from computer A to computer B. I've done this several times in the past. I used to get the "Moved it o...
Replies
7
Views
3,424
Hi. Currently I am at work using VMware Workstation 10, with great success. Now, for my private use, I am thinking about using Virtual Box or...
Replies
7
Views
3,869
Greetings all. I am having a new problem with my VM. Host OS is 11 and VM OS is 10. I have two smaller monitors that connect to my laptop which...
Replies
6
Views
596
So, I have a little dillemma I am trying to work through but I feel there is probably a better way. I've always liked the idea of using a VM in...
Replies
5
Views
2,116
*VMWare vCenter Converter Standalone version 6.3 & 6.4 Hello Experts I want to convert my current physical hardware machine to a virtual...
Replies
2
Views
1,676
Back
Top Bottom