Terry Woods
Member
- Join Date
- Apr 2002
- Posts
- 3,170
Bob...
The shape of the arm makes no difference what so ever.
All that matters is the distance between the nut and the point where the force is applied, and the force.
The arm could be "I-shaped", "S-shaped", "L-shaped"... any shape at all.
How can the nut be sensitive to the type of arm being applied?
Could the nut say... "ooohhh... S-shape", or... "ooohhh... L-shape".
What would the effective arm length be if the 12" torque wrench was applied at 90-degrees to the metric wrench.
Just to make sure we are all on the same page... the two wrenches are in the same plane, horizontal.
The effective length of the arm is the square root of (9-squared + 12-squared).
81 + 144 = 225
sq root of 225 = 15
The effective length of the arm is 15" (1.25-Ft).
What you are doing is "projecting" the horizontal component of the torque wrench onto the axis with the metric wrench. (that is what I did the first time as well.)
In the case of the 30-degree angle... (1-Ft COS 30 = .866-Ft) you are calculating an effective length of .750-Ft + .866-Ft = 1.616-Ft
In the case of the 90-degree angle... (1-Ft COS 90 = 0.000-Ft) that would be... .750-Ft + .000-Ft = .750-Ft
Both of those are wrong.
The shape of the arm makes no difference what so ever.
All that matters is the distance between the nut and the point where the force is applied, and the force.
The arm could be "I-shaped", "S-shaped", "L-shaped"... any shape at all.
How can the nut be sensitive to the type of arm being applied?
Could the nut say... "ooohhh... S-shape", or... "ooohhh... L-shape".
What would the effective arm length be if the 12" torque wrench was applied at 90-degrees to the metric wrench.
Just to make sure we are all on the same page... the two wrenches are in the same plane, horizontal.
o
|
/ |
/ |
/ |
/ 12"
/ |
/ |
/ |
/ |
o----- 9" -------o
The effective length of the arm is the square root of (9-squared + 12-squared).
81 + 144 = 225
sq root of 225 = 15
The effective length of the arm is 15" (1.25-Ft).
What you are doing is "projecting" the horizontal component of the torque wrench onto the axis with the metric wrench. (that is what I did the first time as well.)
In the case of the 30-degree angle... (1-Ft COS 30 = .866-Ft) you are calculating an effective length of .750-Ft + .866-Ft = 1.616-Ft
In the case of the 90-degree angle... (1-Ft COS 90 = 0.000-Ft) that would be... .750-Ft + .000-Ft = .750-Ft
Both of those are wrong.